Shawn Ray when he won the Nationals, Kai Green at the New York Pro show, Ed Corney pic any show, Darrem Charles Rome pro win, Melvin Anthony 06 Olympia, Lee Labrada pic any Show! The most consistent poser would have to be Lee Labrada. Labrada was a true Uncrowned Mr. Olympia if they had a 202 class then he would have won every single one of them.
Although, I don't really think his posing was real great, his athleticism is shown through his routine. The horizontal hand stand is pretty impressive. Not sure about the stage humping, the cheesy strut or the tacky 80's music, but all in all, good routine... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c2RVmrUlzhE&feature=related