I guess maybe I don't understand how this all works then. I saw the emails and protocols he had sent my buddy and they are much more detailed than what you described.
It is extremely difficult and not practical for anyone working a normal or demanding career to adhere to any of that, my boy did but it was very difficult and he's an ultra motivated dude with an insane work ethic.
I would imagine it would be difficult to find a coach who will let you eat what you decide and work less than he recommends.
Sometimes what we have to do vs what is comfortable to do is not going to give you the same results... which is exactly why it's recommended.
There's a lot to be said about this subject, and I've hesitated to weigh in. But here's a few thoughts as someone who's been coaching for a short period of time (about a year) and has never had more than a relatively small number of clients (~10):
- There's a sad reality/paradox where the more well-known you are, the more incentive there is to tend towards a cookie-cutter approach.
- The truth is that these approaches absolutely work, as evidenced by the most recent anecdote. Unfortunately, its possible for a client to get "in the best shape of their life" and also have had it have been exponentially more difficult than it needed to be, or took longer than it needed to, or damaging long term from a health perspective, etc.
- Every single client I've had who has had prior coaching has at least one if not multiple horror stories from being coached by a "big name". In each instance, they said "screw it, I'm gonna hire one of the best", and in each case were provided with something that felt very cookie cutter and had to deal with the coach seeming to not even read their emails, etc. Where I'm worried that I'm not providing quite the service level they need or want, they've all remarked at how much attention I give relative to what they expected or are used to, etc.
- Sadly, I think this trend will continue for some time, as we're having a bit of a boom and there are plenty of guys ready to take the place of a disgruntled client who moves on.
- That being said, I do think in a few years (maybe longer) we will see the bottom start to fall out for a lot of the more established guys. There was a time when there really were only a small number of guys with the knowledge and experience that we now look as "basic" and "cookie cutter", and that's changing rapidly. The guys who don't adapt and stay on the cutting edge, and develop a more personalized approach will realize their "O.G. name" isn't worth as much as it was at some point. That could be wishful thinking on my part.
- It's easy for me to say this stuff as a coach without an established name and a small client base, but I am fairly confident that were I to establish a name for myself and the kind of demand that some of these guys have, that there's a way to do it "right" that will start to become to normal paradigm for coaching in the future. I'd like to think so, anyway.
I want to make it clear that this isn't directed at Bleu specifically; I have a friend who's an IFBB Pro who has been with Bleu for awhile and is quite happy with him.