- Joined
- Dec 23, 2024
- Messages
- 1,117
I’ve been following this conversation with great interest, here’s something I’m trying to still understand- saw the video with Dr Scott Stevenson where he discusses training intensity in more detail- also reading through various threads here where we talk about intensity, high volume versus the Dorian/ JP approach, etc.
One thing I’m wondering is this- just like pain and pain tolerance are individual (and I assume will affect an individuals ability to reach true failure, 1 RIR, whatever)- then watched the Mentzer bicep training video someone posted here, where he mentions how one true failure set is all that is truly needed to give the muscle stimulation it needs to signal growth-
Is it fair to say that if you’re a person that struggles with all out intensity (compared to others), adding quality volume is the only other way to guarantee enough stimulus to send that growth signal?
In other words- are both approaches equally viable if done properly and all things being equal? And then it’s just a matter of figuring out which one works best for the individual (which one allows for better recovery, less injury or joint wear and tear, etc)?
One thing I’m wondering is this- just like pain and pain tolerance are individual (and I assume will affect an individuals ability to reach true failure, 1 RIR, whatever)- then watched the Mentzer bicep training video someone posted here, where he mentions how one true failure set is all that is truly needed to give the muscle stimulation it needs to signal growth-
Is it fair to say that if you’re a person that struggles with all out intensity (compared to others), adding quality volume is the only other way to guarantee enough stimulus to send that growth signal?
In other words- are both approaches equally viable if done properly and all things being equal? And then it’s just a matter of figuring out which one works best for the individual (which one allows for better recovery, less injury or joint wear and tear, etc)?











































































