guys, this debate should never be or include what people outside of this industry think.. vander brings up that he talsk to a lot of people from various back grounds but, no offense, WHO CARES WHAT THEY THINK? they would never buy a ticket to a show.. sure.. if you showed a picture of frank sepe and a pic of dorian most outside of this industry would pick sepe.. but again WHO GIVES A DAMN? now show that same picture to ticket buyers and bodybuilder and see what they say.. completely different.. again.. the wqeiders tried to make it mainstream.. they have had 40 years of trying..NO GO.. vince mcmahon tried again.. he poured tons of money into it.. NO GO.. the physiques of the past could not get the public to give a shit.. the physiques now can not give a person to give a shit.. i know a lot of writers in this industry and many pros.. i talk to them fairly regular.. all agree about one thing.. IT WILL NEVER HAVE MAINSTREAM EXCEPTANCE SO LETS STOP TALKING ABOUT IT.. the sport is excepted by those who particpate.. they all also agree that FREAKS SELL THE TICKETS.. haney was considered a freak at 245 pounds.. arnold was considered a freak amongst his peers.. sergio ect ect.. like i stated before.. even if they all showed up looking like a combination of darrem and sepe rolled into one, the general public would not buy a ticket to see it.. but, you would lose a tremendous amount of support among the hardcore fans.. ben weider was shot down numerous times in regards to olympic exceptance.. he just will not learn..
the physiques of old would not impress the buyers of most of the magazines today.. like i stated before.. arnold would have taken what ever it took to succeed .. if igf and slin were available he would have taken it.. you can not regulate what people are using .. arnold, according to ric drasin, his training partner, told of arnold taking dbol by THE BOTTLE FULL.. DAILY.. same for serge nubret.. robert kennedy , owner of muscle mag international magazine, told of watching serge nubret take a handful of dbol with each meal.. they had a "classic" physique in spite of themselves..
i think we can all agree that we all hate big bloated guts.. no question there.. i think we can all agree that sythol used wrong can be very distractingh to a physique.. but, i think it is foolish to say that a 270 lbs competitor can not have symmetry or a pleasing physique.. guys who stated that they do not want to get any bigger, like those in the new flex mag, can hardly be considered gym warriors.. train to maintain? forget that crap.. boring.. ill support the nabba or another organization if ami does stupid crap like this.. the sport has room for all types of physiques but, if the ifbb is taking this attitude that smaller physiques are somehow more healthy they are fooling themselves... dexter has gained 100 pounds since he started bodybuilding.. so has ronnie.. why is dexters 100 pound gain healthier than ronnies? dxter at 5'6 gains 100 poundsto 230.. ronnie gains 100 pounds to 290.. ronnie is 6'0 ft tall.. now.. who is healthier>? they obviously both took ample amounts of gear to getthat way.. dexter would more than likely have to take similar dosages.. his genes just do not allow for a massive look.. if you watch haidar trauin.. he trains with very heavy weights and does sets similar to ronnie.. yet he is not massive.. why? cause his genes do not allow it.. yet there is ignorance by those who assume that he is healthier.. yet for all the weight he slings, haidar is only known for his symmetry..he is small.. put ronnie through the same workouts and he becomes a freak.. ronnie responds better.. so does it not make sense that maybe ronnie responds better to gear also? maybe ronnie needs a hell of a lot less than we think due to his great genes.. maybe haidar is the one abusing just to be symmetrical ..
whne looking at the physiques of the "golden era" we can also surmise that sergio had the best genetics given to anyone in that time.. his waist was smaller than arnolds by far.. his quads and hams were huge and veiney.. he also worked in a foundery all day putting in 12 hour days and eating beans hotdogs and drinking cokes.. yet he still won a few mr olympias.. atrnol on the other hand, was catered to.. weider gave him a place to live. weider gave him money.. he laid on the beach and trained.. eat well.. yet his ophysique was not any better than sergios for all the pampering he had.. danny padilla, boyer coe and many others said that arnold was not as good as sergio..arnold has since admitted that sergio had much better genetics for bodybuilding.. there were some good physiques for that time.. but, most, even with todays knowledge and supplements would not be special in comparison to todays competitors.. the gene pool has widened and more guys are involved.. the gene pool was shallow at that time.. not many competitors.. the physiques were classic in many instances because they were not big and they were one of just a few.. they took ample gear.. hell it was cheap and legal.. they trained and lifted and got , by todays standards, physiques that would not win a state title.. some were very good.. arnold, sergio, nubret, columbo, paddila..but, even arnold has admitted that he would have a tough time today on the state level.. that is not to diminish what they accomplished for us as bodybuilders today.. but, those "classic" physiques are very mediocre by todays standards.. (that being said , swergio is still favorite bodybuilder and one of the few, given todays knolwedge that could be competitive) i love to think of arnold and sergio ect training at golds and i love those old time black and white training photos.. but, they are just looking into the past.. they were great then.. not now.. some may espire to look like them.. but, you will not do it with out ample drugs.. they used good amounts.. danny padilla had open heart surgery.. boyer coe had open heart surgery.. arnold had open heart surgery... ed corney has had a massive stroke and heart complications.. sergios joints are shot .. how are thse guys healthier than todays guys?... maybe they are linked to their massive usage.. maybe not.. but look athe number of health problems in regards to the golden age old timers compared to how many competed.. looks kinda like today.. so what ia m saying is they used massive amounts and "only" achieved a "classic" physique.. the gene pool had less to draw from.. they got a smaller physique comapred to the guys of today.. but, it was not from a lack of "trying".. lol
if weider and the ifbb want a return of the "golden age" they better look a little closer.. it does not appear any different than today.. drug use.. drug use.. but, they "appeared" to take less..
the hypocrisy of the ifbb is disgusting.. arnold wants to have future political ambitions and he is giving it to us in the shorts.. do not think that his taking over muscle and fitness as a "editor" is not responsible.. he is getting heat from others and he is trying to look good.. all the while he did the same thing.. and lots of it..