I am with J Smiles all the way. Sure keto can be effective for some but there are better ways and you won't get all the negatives keto usually brings. But yeah very small numbers love the approach. So do it if you want but then hire someone like phil later in the future and see what approach gives you the best results and what approach do you feel best on.
The above debate is interesting but step back from all this caveman crap etc... you are depriving yourself of one of the most important nutrients. Lots more to it but you have protein, fat and carbs (fiber etc). Those 3 categories are vital. Why would you take one away. Extreme diets never work long term... the key is balance.
I have the same opinion as Lee Haney when it comes to Keto diets
Just adding kid1 I really like reading your posts and you provide great info and are a valuable member. I agree with you about the sugars and processed foods. But the unhealthy people you see everyday are not like most on this board. If you eat crap and are inactive your not gonna be of good health over time. Everyone ha different opinons and hey many have no fat or believe one should not have more than 100g protein per day but for me the key is balance and what feels best.
Thanks for the kind words.
I have to respond about the part about the unhealthy patients being different as JS also said "apples and oranges" well yes and no.
That would be the easy thing to group them separately and move on but there are similarities.
I keep mental notes and do some surveys and have learned some things.
Just to name a couple Athletes and unhealthy both:
Inflammatory indicators are higher in
all patients that eat grains.
Cholesterol is higher also,part of the reason the body raises cholesterol is to soothe inflammation.
Those who follow a mediteranean type diet seem to heal faster and respond quicker to certain therapies.
I am very observant and eager to learn so I look for similarities and differences in both health athletic people and sedentary sick patients.
I am just telling you guys what I have learned by reading journals,school,doing nutritional counseling etc...
The stuff I mentioned about some history with conditions and agriculture is factual and not some opinion I have as some moron stated.
I try to come on here and share what I know in areas I am educated such as nutrition and pharmacology but it gets frustrating.
My best friend is an interventional radiologist who also trains.He came on here and said"fuck it" as people argued and told him he was wrong and called him a "newbie".This was by someone a lot of people on this board respect, he doesn't know a fraction about the human body and pharmacology as this Well educated Specialist does.
Sorry for the rant but the broscience parroting and "supposed" guru quoting and uneducated strong opinions vs. facts by some gets old.I don't pretend to know everything by any means, but, I will say if I DON't KNOW SOMETHING FOR AN ABSOLUTE FACT I will STFU and not chime in.
Lee Haney lectured in Atlanta georgia in Aug.1997 I WAS THERE! He said eat according to what you are doing for the next few hours.If training or very active eat protein and carbs.If not training eat mainly protein. He felt you could lose fat and gain muscle with this approach.He never mentioned pineapple juice for the record.