x2
It's one thing to come from using loads of hormones to going down to testosterone level of a healthy youug man to basically shutting down your entire system. I think a lot of these coaches are simply old school and they do what they always have even if it's not optimal.
I know many coaches (Palumbo, Aceto, Tuor) who get guys to come off completely and no you are not going to get better results in the long run. You get amazing results because you basically start losing everything and start feeling like crap then bang back on.
Dev on here is a good exmaple of using a coach recently who follows the ways of Chris Aceto. He had him come off then go straight back on which in most ways is completely pointless. He didn't give him the needed time to come off and in the end it was a pointless endeavour and Dev will tell you that.
Now if you are coming off for a mental break then that is different and you come off and get what you need from that. Many guys start banging in the likes of HCG and clomid so they don't even come off but again have that mental break and go back on. They convince themselves it has suddenly cleaned their receptors and they are fresh again and it's nonsense. Anyone who has studied the science of this will tell you that.
It's mainly just a mental thing and that's great... I have come off everything myself many times. Obviously when I say a mental thing you notice it physically more than anything. Yes I blow back up super fast and feel great but that's because I have been shut down and literally melting away over the prior 2 months
If you go on 10-20mg test per day for example you are getting that break you need without crashing your system. Therefore you are losing much less and not doing any of this yoyoing. Yes if you come off you blow back up but why go through the crash and surges in cortisol, estrogen etc when you can pretty much feel good and get the break from hormones you need. Plus on trt you can maintain well so you never go too far backwards like you would if coming off for 4 months. That way you should be able to make more gains in the future. Although your gains are very genetic and regardless of the way you do thing (coming off or trt) you are gonna end up probably looking the same anyway.
Look at it this way what's the point in feeling like shit for months with no sex drive etc for pretty much nothing in return.