You are so right about the Columbus gym scene!! I live in the area...been here since 1994. It was much better back in the day with the World Gym's (I think there were about 7 locations back then). I trained at the huge one up in Worthington where I'd regularly see Francois and JM Blakely. I'd also train at the one in Dublin off of Sawmill Rd. That was a good one too but it's gone now. Back then I was going back and forth between powerlifting and bodybuilding so those locations were well equipped for both! In the late 90's, my wife and I moved to Hilliard and I joined the Power Shack there at Mill Run...another good gym for powerlifting and bodybuilding. I think it's still there actually.
Starting in the early 2000's I bought a power rack and started training in my basement half the time. I loved it and made my mind up to start going in that direction more and more over time. A crazy thing happened in 2008 (housing bubble crash) and there were many gyms in the Columbus area that went out of business and had public auctions to sell their equipment. I went to a couple auctions at the Metro Fitness locations. Remember them? That's what the World Gyms changed their name to. I felt bad for them but it was a huge win for me! I bought so much stuff at those auctions for literally what amounted to pennies on the dollar! All of a sudden, I had a really nice, fully equipped home gym in my basement and I made the complete switch to home gym training full time and haven't looked back since!
Now, my wife and kids actually enjoy going to a gym instead of training in my awesome basement so we have a membership to the central Ohio YMCA's. Every once in a while, I go with them and just mess around on some machines and do some cardio and I'm quickly reminded why I love training at home!! I also travel a little bit for work and they pay for me to have a Planet Fitness membership because they have locations EVERYWHERE!!
But you're right....so many of the BEST facilities (Wenning, EliteFTS, Westside, etc.) are private/invitation only. I've been inside the EliteFTS gym and it's RIDICULOUS!! Didn't train there though. I was just out there cuz I bought a couple things from the EliteFTS store and wanted to save a little bit on shipping so I just drove out there to pick the stuff up. I started chatting Dave up and he took me over to the gym and showed me around. Pretty awesome place! I remember when he first started Elitefts and when you'd call there he actually answered the phone...lol.
Another cool story from back in the day: This was early 1995 and I had been in Columbus about 6 months. Like I said earlier, I was trying to get stronger in powerlifting and had a subscription to Powerlifting USA and was reading the articles Louie was writing about his conjugate system. He was selling VHS tapes of actual workouts at the time. I called the Westside phone number he had posted in his articles and damn if he didn't answer the phone!! I told him I wanted to buy a couple of his tapes and that I was local and would just come pick them up. He told me to meet him at the gym that evening and he'd have them there. This was back when Westside was on Demorest Ave. The OG, hard-core Westside with the windows painted black and where all of those tapes were filmed and where Dave, Chuck, Kenny Patterson, George Halbert, etc started coming up. So I meet Louie there and he has my tapes and I start asking him questions. Finally after about 10 minutes, Louie says "how about I just take you through a dynamic bench workout so you'll know what it's supposed to be like. He kicked my ass for 45 minutes but it's something I'll never forget!
I've never been there but I think American Barbell down in Canal Winchester on the southeast side of town is a really nice gym. That's where John Meadows trained a lot and where he filmed a lot of his YouTube stuff before he passed.