Would the best Jay Cutler win this years olympia?

[iron lifter]

If the best version of Jay Cutler entered this years Olympia would he win?

 

[TrippplePPP]

I would have to look at pics to figure out what I think is his best look but I think 2009 was the year he came back after loosing to Dexter and that version always stuck out to me as his best. I do believe he would go neck and neck with Ramy yet I think he would take Nic Walker though. He would take Brandon for sure. I could not see any one else topping him either in the line up.

 

[pistonpump]

I don't think he wins

 

[Brock456]

Hell yeah he would. He beat the GOAT Ronnie. What makes you think he wouldn’t beat any of these guys?

 

[pistonpump]

Hell yeah he would. He beat the GOAT Ronnie. What makes you think he wouldn’t beat any of these guys?

He beat Ronnie playing the ronnie game he was being compared to Ronnie but I think the top physiques have a different look now. Jay won cu he matched size but I don't think he has nice lines like guys in the top now with way more detail. Flame me if u want lol but wasn't a huge fan of Jay's physique. I guess hard to tell until standing side by side w the current guys

 

[Gizmo]

I think he wins

 

[pistonpump]

I think he wins

View attachment 168780

touche

 

[FK86]

Hell yeah he would. He beat the GOAT Ronnie. What makes you think he wouldn’t beat any of these guys?

He beat a lesser Ronnie. He's repeatedly acknowledged he didn't beat the best version of Coleman and doesn't know if he could have.

I think he would beat this year's lineup if he was 2001 Olympia, 2003 Ironman, or 2009 Olympia Jay.

 

[Brock456]

He beat a lesser Ronnie. He's repeatedly acknowledged he didn't beat the best version of Coleman and doesn't know if he could have.

I think he would beat this year's lineup if he was 2001 Olympia, 2003 Ironman, or 2009 Olympia Jay.

Even when he didn’t beat Ronnie, he mostly finished 2nd to Ronnie.

I don’t think any of these guys come close to that!

 

[Elvia1023]

I think he wins especially if you go by last years Olympia. This years O I wouldn't be so confident stating that and hopefully Ramy, Brandon, Hadi and Nick are all improved from last year.

 

[TrippplePPP]

I think he wins especially if you go by last years Olympia. This years O I wouldn't be so confident stating that and hopefully Ramy, Brandon, Hadi and Nick are all improved from last year.

I think a 2009 Jay beats last years line up for sure.

 

[UnholyAlliance]

I think he wins

View attachment 168780

If Jay were to compete now and came in at that same level of conditioning as back in 2009 he'd be able to beat Ramy now even by a whisker.

 

[dantes]

I mean only two guys can be beat Jay at his best, Ronnie and probably Phil but I think it would be close between him an Phil. Maybe Dorian gives him a run aswell but I think Jay probably beats Dorian

 

[Hammer4]

I think he wins

View attachment 168780

The bleached blonde tips though haha... ah the 00's

 

[marssel]

If the best version of Jay Cutler entered this years Olympia would he win?

He would win without breaking a sweat as would Phil at his best. Curry will be at his best and won’t

 

[oxandrin]

Def 2009 Jay would be taking home the Sandow

 

[marssel]

Def 2009 Jay would be taking home the Sandow

And prolly missing actual competition to push him. He was always chasing or was being pushed by an amazing bodybuilder.

 

[IFBBProDomCardone]

Absolutely

 

[w8tlifterty]

Absolutely

As a guy that’s been around the sport in recent years and reached a certain level…. I’d be curious to hear what you think about the current level of physiques.

I mean, Ronnie/Jay/Phil would wax at peak, any one of these current competitors from my naked eye. It seems like somehow the sport (or whatever you prefer to call it) is devolving?

 

[B Ware]

Absolutely Jay would win