I have tried literally every self tanning lotion made. Read reviews, bought the most expensive to that "secret unknown, but works formula" and to me, they all suck and yield less then positive comments from people. Especially my girlfriends, all hate the color it gives me. Fake, orange sort of look. No matter what you use.
So I just tan. I let it fade some and then hit it again a few times per month. I'm getting older and for sure notice the damaging affects of years of tanning, but it's not too bad yet. I am 50, so what can I expect, I started tanning at age 14.
Anyhow, tanning lotions and all that spay on tan shit sucks. Totally fake and trust me, 100% of everyone around you will know you're using it. It stinks too, especially when you get sweaty during sex.