I can't believe this is even up for debate. How many holiday songs mention pecan pie? None that I know of. How many pecan pie lattes does starbucks sell every holiday season? Fucking zero. That's how many. Did Linus and Sally ditch trick or treating to stay up all night waiting for "The Great Pecan"? Hell no, it was...wait for it...wait for it...yup that's right..."The Great PUMPKIN".
Pumpkin pie all the way.