Well I will admit..Jim Brown is who I modeled myself after when I played halfback.
Jim is a living legend. You are 100% correct about about Payton. The Bears sucked big time...I was born and raised in Chicago..Southside baby!!
Payton was the most complete back ever. I think Jim Brown was the most dominating.
I still say Payton is the greatest..No comp!!
#1- Walter Payton
#2- Eric Dickerson
#3- Barry Sanders
#4- Jim Brown
#5- Gale Sayers
Read this and weep Vander..lol
Payton was the best, is the best and always will be the best. Payton was the purest football player ever, he was the best blocker of any running back in NFL history, there is no comparison in that category. He rushed for 16726 yards in only 13 years, he had at least 3-4 good years left in him, and if he hadn’t retired, could have amassed over 20,000 yards. You can say Emmitt is the best, based on yards, and if you base it on yards, he is the best, but you see, you can base things on just yards. If you only do this on one criteria, then it isn’t worth posting. You have to add in receiving, blocking and lots of other things, like leadership. Payton was an amazing leader, Jim Brown and Emmitt Smith were not. Payton was the greatest blocker of any running back in NFL history. Payton had 492 receptions, 4538 yards and 15 touchdown receptions. Just look at it! the only running back who is a better receiver is Marshall Faulk. Okay, I can keep rambling on like this but I don’t think I am convincing you. Okay, Smith I think was lucky to be in such a good situation in Dallas, I mean, it was perfect. Payton’s situation was not perfect, he got stuck in Chicago and with a team that had been losers for the past 5 or more years. Payton led the Bears to the Super Bowl in 1985 and it was one of the greatest seasons in NFL History, the Bears also did this without a Troy Aikman type quarterback or a Michael Irvin type wide receiver, they did it with Walter Payton rushing for 1551 yards and Jim McMahon at quarterback. If you take Aikman off of the Cowboys, your taking away 3 rings, if you take McMahon away, then the Bears still would have one the Super Bowl. Payton had more of an effect on his team then Smith ever had on his. Payton went to 9 pro bowl’s and Smith went to 8. Okay, if all of this doesn’t convince you, then I don’t know what will.
Payton is the greatest running back ever to put on cleats. Make your argument for who is number one