Actually in an industrialized society, women are attracted to a man's financial strength rather than his physical strength.
They think that, but it’s in their animal physiology to want a protector
Funny enough, you're both 1/4th correct. Women will often seek out a male who can bear children with the skills, intelligence, and ability to be successful ("rich") in a modern while often harboring desires for the male with great physical strength and prowess.
This plays out in a scenarios or variations where the woman will marry the wealthy, successful sensitive type while having a sexual affair with the tanned, well-muscled gardener. This is a cliche but as I said can play out in many forms.
So you both combined got 1/2 the equation. The other half is that women (and men, too) are complex enough to experience a desire for any of a vast spectrum of qualities. Things that may be similar to her father, his eyes, smile, the sound of his voice, she digs thin guys, she digs bald guys, etc. Or maybe he's moderately successful, moderately handsome, and moderately strong and average size but the total = good match.
Human beings are complex. She may not want a man at all. Or maybe she doesn't want a man but rather a woman. Perhaps her father was abusive or her mother was emotionally distant. Blanket statements and characterizations don't work in H.s.sapiens.