Sometimes these "reviews" are by people with 3 posts
But if positive, the reviews stand and considered legit, right?
Comments like this should be between you and 'brand-x'.
Meaning what? If a sponsor blows it, it needs to be kept off the board? How is that helpful to the rest of the members? The positive stuff is posted, any problems need to be private?
I can totally understand "protecting" sponsors, hey, they pay, but seriously. If the owner is allowing heads-up sponsors, there won't be an issue? Take whoever is willing to pay for ad space? Surely, that isn't happening here. Right?
That being said, the net is full of whiners... with their bs stories of getting screwed, speaking too soon, foot in the mouth, etc., thats what makes being a mod tough. I own a forum (not BB related) with 76,000 members, have 23 mods and can appreciate the difficulty of making the judgement calls, but to openly state that the advertisers are covered no matter what is just a tad worrisome, when you consider the $$ involved and the fact that people are pumping the stuff into muscle.
I came to this board looking for a new "sponsor" since the recent enforcement took out 3 of my guys (and boards) and YES found a great one here. For that I'm appreciative. The service is top notch as well as the quality of the product. Fact is, I'm buying the stuff as fast as I can afford it before the source goes away or dries-up, even though I'm paying double what I did a year ago. If I had a problem with the source, I can't post it in the 20+ page thread of praise? Looking over that page, the VAST majority of posts (positive) were by members with less than 20 posts or one member in particular who's 50 or so total posts are made up of 90% sponsor praise.... Yet, low post count members with something negative to say are deleted or dismissed as noobs with an agenda? We members aren't intelligent enough to read an uncensored thread and come to our own conclusions? Maybe not.
I suppose "questioning the powers that be" may get the post deleted and/or me banned... oh well, I just couldn't help myself
Just some random thoughts.