What does it take to be an NPC judge?

[Future]

Apparently a heartbeat is the big thing. Watching the judging I saw alot of inconsistencies at the Beverly Show. It was hard to determine who and why several times.

What really does it take to become an NPC judge? And honestly, do these people even have a bodybuilding background?

 

[Future]

Well....she took 3rd. I am not sure why. She honestly was the better physique. Not sure what the deal was. Still she did really well. She was good about talking about her weaknesses that could have kept her from clearly winning.

One note, the crowd really sucks with womens competitions. They were quite during the open stuff. Shows what they think of the competitors I guess.

I am not sure if it was politics or what. Being a Beverly Intl show, we were aware that many Bev athletes win. I hope that wasnt the case. It was odd that she was compared TO during prejudging but somehow from that point on took 3rd?

In idiot fashion, I booed. I even made myself look REALLY classy sitting behind the judges telling them they were fucking idiots. BUT THEY REALLY WERE. Still, Tami was happy and that is all that matters in the journey. She wants to NEVER do the Bev show again though....so I think whether she will admit it, she knows she got screwed.

 

[Strunk]

In my state, I had to test judge 2 times before I given the OK. Your scores are suposed to be withing 90% of the head judges scores. My State's head judge is also a National judge. Even once your an NPC judge, the head judge will still "look" at all the scores to make sure everything is ok and favorites are not being played. Say 6 judges scored an athlete anywhere from 5th-6th place votes and another judge scored them in 2nd...this will raise suspicion and something will be done. Once your an NPC judge doesn't always mean you will be.
On the Bbing background...everyone that I know that judges has competed at one time or another. However, I can admit that it doesn't make them a better judge. I know a top National level Bber who is a judge and his scores are some of the worst I've ever seen. I guess this can be realated to Chad Nicholls prep. Chad's one of the best prep gurus in the world, but really hasn't done much as far as Bbing goes.
BBing is such a subjective sport, especially the female side of things right now. We all have guidelines to follow, but usually two people don't see it exactly the same. Did she ask any of the judges why she placed the way she did? If she was at the top of the class, they should all be able to tell her why. The top 10, I'm always good for...but honestly it's always hard for me to tell someone that placed 18th out of 25 guys wanting to know why he was placed low and what he needs to work on.

 

[Future]

Yeah Tami is awesome. She is being so positive and excited. I personally am being an ass about the thing. I am way tooooo protective. She is excited to do the Indy show. She has the bug. I am really proud of her and her attitude. I on the other hand need more xanax and some Dr. Phil hugs.

 

[doug1]

In idiot fashion, I booed. I even made myself look REALLY classy sitting behind the judges telling them they were fucking idiots. BUT THEY REALLY WERE.

bet they just loved that...and you

 

[MAINEVENT]

Future: I think its harder on the significant other than the athlete sometimes. I know your pissed but whats done is done... and unfortunately thats what happens in these competitions. Thats also why alot of people quit competing..

At this point as long as I get better each competition, thats all that matters.......NOW. I used to think differently, but you cant control what other people think. Dont get me wrong, I want to win but I dont let it get to me like I use to.

Just get through the next competition and see what happens after that.

 

[oldfella]

Future, It is hard to swallow sometimes. I know, I have been on the receiveing end of a bad call or two by the judges. it is all an experience and it sounds like tami is on a good ride at the moment. Whenever there are humans involved in judgeing anything we must not forget about individuals tastes. What one judge finds appealling another may disagree. That is why they have guidelines to adhere to. This is not to say they will always follow them! You need to put this one behind you and look forward. look to improve the weak areas. I have seen some top quality physiques places low for bad posing, tattoos, grooming etc. This is BBing. Why not post up some pics or video footage and let the promuscle community be the judges. There are not only judges here but a hell of a lot of Comp experienced people. We are here to help each other acheive our goals and you would have some excellent feed back for sure. This would give you the ammunition for the next round. Third is a very respectable placing in any show, I'd say Tami should be proud of this achievement and move forward. i look forward to seeing some comparison shots and I will speak for myself, I will give you my honest opinion.
CONGRATULATIONS to you Tami! That is a good effort and I look forward to seeing more of you!