You guys have done a great job answering this excellent question. I love this question. How much muscle can you gain and keep from a cycle.
My opinion is this... People often mistake numbers on a scale for muscle. That is not correct. When you start your cycle you often gain water and hold it so your going to gain weight right away. This is not muscle fiber. Basically when its all said and done, how much quality did you gain, not quantitity.
I would take quality over quantitiy any day bros! its how good you look. If you gain a few pounds of lean mass that is great! And thats all one should realiscally expect. Bodybuilding is not somthing that can be rushed. Sure you can, but again, Im striving for quality.
And in the end I want to have lean, ripped tissue on display not just bulk and water under my skin and big numbers on a scale.
Personally i have gained 20lbs of lean tissue in 5 years, And my conditioninig is pretty damn good. This is on average 4lbs a year.
Im helping several guys here and i often remind them to hide their scale. Because the scale can undermine you. Its not how much you weigh but what you look like and feel like.
Im doing the nationals again this year and will probably lose about 7lbs from start of my 16 week diet to the end like i did last year. And I look like i gained weight. So I did lose weight(fat) but put on muscle while dieting. This is the ideal situation.