.gif "IP Gear")
- Joined
- Jun 10, 2002
- Messages
- 267
Many were appalled when I post the story that Noelle Bush was found with crack in her shoe and Jeb Bush said it should be treated as a family matter. Here is a follow up in the news today:
ORLANDO, Florida (AP) -- An attorney for Gov. Jeb Bush's only daughter asked a judge Tuesday to close her drug court proceedings, arguing that she has a right to privacy while under that court's supervision.
Drug courts help a person complete treatment and aren't subject to the same openness as criminal courts, lawyer Peter Antonacci argued.
An attorney for the Orlando Sentinel and the South Florida Sun-Sentinel newspapers said drug courts are no different than any other criminal court and should stay open.
"This decides whether she goes to jail to or not," said Jonathan Kaney, an attorney who specializes in First Amendment issues. He said there was no "celebrity exception to the rule of openness in court."
The judge didn't say when he would make a decision.
Noelle Bush, 25, was arrested last January for buying an anti-anxiety drug with a fraudulent prescription. She sought treatment through a drug court, but could face criminal charges if she fails the treatment.
Last July, Bush spent two days in jail for possessing a prescription drug. Last month, police were called to her treatment center in Orlando after another patient said Bush had crack cocaine.
Speaking to reporters in Tallahassee, Gov. Jeb Bush said drug courts should be protected from public scrutiny.
"At a point in time, people can be looked at as though they're failing when in fact if you look at it over the long haul, they're on the road to recovery," he said.
Carolyn Cooper, associate director of the Drug Court Clearinghouse at American University in Washington, said she never heard of a drug court hearing being closed to the public. Neither had Karen Freeman-Wilson, chief executive of the National Association of Drug Court Professionals in Washington.
If the judge rules in favor of Noelle Bush, it would go against the grain of the First Amendment since court proceedings are closed to the public only under rare circumstances, said Gary Winick, a law professor at the University of Miami.
"Our tradition is one of openness," Winick said. "What happens in a courtroom is of strong public interest."
ORLANDO, Florida (AP) -- An attorney for Gov. Jeb Bush's only daughter asked a judge Tuesday to close her drug court proceedings, arguing that she has a right to privacy while under that court's supervision.
Drug courts help a person complete treatment and aren't subject to the same openness as criminal courts, lawyer Peter Antonacci argued.
An attorney for the Orlando Sentinel and the South Florida Sun-Sentinel newspapers said drug courts are no different than any other criminal court and should stay open.
"This decides whether she goes to jail to or not," said Jonathan Kaney, an attorney who specializes in First Amendment issues. He said there was no "celebrity exception to the rule of openness in court."
The judge didn't say when he would make a decision.
Noelle Bush, 25, was arrested last January for buying an anti-anxiety drug with a fraudulent prescription. She sought treatment through a drug court, but could face criminal charges if she fails the treatment.
Last July, Bush spent two days in jail for possessing a prescription drug. Last month, police were called to her treatment center in Orlando after another patient said Bush had crack cocaine.
Speaking to reporters in Tallahassee, Gov. Jeb Bush said drug courts should be protected from public scrutiny.
"At a point in time, people can be looked at as though they're failing when in fact if you look at it over the long haul, they're on the road to recovery," he said.
Carolyn Cooper, associate director of the Drug Court Clearinghouse at American University in Washington, said she never heard of a drug court hearing being closed to the public. Neither had Karen Freeman-Wilson, chief executive of the National Association of Drug Court Professionals in Washington.
If the judge rules in favor of Noelle Bush, it would go against the grain of the First Amendment since court proceedings are closed to the public only under rare circumstances, said Gary Winick, a law professor at the University of Miami.
"Our tradition is one of openness," Winick said. "What happens in a courtroom is of strong public interest."
