• All new members please introduce your self here and welcome to the board:
    http://www.professionalmuscle.com/forums/showthread.php?t=259
Buy Needles And Syringes With No Prescription
M4B Store Banner
intex
Riptropin Store banner
Generation X Bodybuilding Forum
Buy Needles And Syringes With No Prescription
Buy Needles And Syringes With No Prescription
Mysupps Store Banner
IP Gear Store Banner
PM-Ace-Labs
Ganabol Store Banner
Spend $100 and get bonus needles free at sterile syringes
Professional Muscle Store open now
sunrise2
PHARMAHGH1
kinglab
ganabol2
Professional Muscle Store open now
over 5000 supplements on sale at professional muscle store
boslabs1
granabolic1
napsgear-210x65
monster210x65
over 5000 supplements on sale at professional muscle store
over 5000 supplements on sale at professional muscle store
DeFiant
UGFREAK-banner-PM
STADAPM
yms-GIF-210x65-SB
over 5000 supplements on sale at professional muscle store
over 5000 supplements on sale at professional muscle store
wuhan2
dpharma
marathon
zzsttmy
over 5000 supplements on sale at professional muscle store
over 5000 supplements on sale at professional muscle store
azteca
crewguru
advertise1x
advertise1x
over 5000 supplements on sale at professional muscle store
over 5000 supplements on sale at professional muscle store
over 5000 supplements on sale at professional muscle store
over 5000 supplements on sale at professional muscle store
over 5000 supplements on sale at professional muscle store
over 5000 supplements on sale at professional muscle store
over 5000 supplements on sale at professional muscle store

Suggestion to Big A

Nssca

Active member
Kilo Klub Member
Registered
Joined
Jun 5, 2002
Messages
1,570
I think it would make this Board complete if we had Physician that would answer questions for the members. Maybe a whole separate forum just for the DOC.
I know that another board has a resident physician.
Just a thought.
 
DaRooster said:
I think it would make this Board complete if we had Physician that would answer questions for the members. Maybe a whole separate forum just for the DOC.
I know that another board has a resident physician.
Just a thought.
i know there are a few (1 or 2) people who have posted semi recently that they are in the medical field...not sure how qualified they are/would be to take on something like that but it could be cool.
 
Great idea, but I would imagine the potential liability issues with giving what could amount to medical advice would be very complex.

I would imagine that interpreting studies and providing information and opinions on very general issues may be safe, but it just seems that the potential risks involved seem rather large for the doctor.
 
An MD is legally qualified to give medical advice.
We give each other medical advice everyday, yet none of us are as qualified as an MD to do so.
 
Last edited:
Agreed. Believe it or not the fact that we are not licensed physicians actually protects us in a way.

If I follow your advice and take too much of whatever and get sick, I have very little chance to find a lawyer to file a civil suit against you. No personal injury lawyer will take my case because you are not a doctor, and can not be easily held accountable for bad advice.

However a doctor is licensed by the state and is a prime target for medical malpractice suits. Not only because he is licensed, but because every lawyer knows that he carries liability insurance. I would have no problem finding any number of lawyers to represent me.

It is really a risk vs. reward situation for a doctor. The risks for him giving what could be viewed by a jury as medical advice on a board that dealing mostly with the illegal use of steroids is huge. He could even lose his license to practice medicine.
 
DaRooster said:
An MD is legally qualified to give medical advice.
We give each other medical advice everyday, yet none of us are as qualified as an MD to do so.


An MD can also tell you to take some penecillin not knowing you were allergic to it and you croak! If you are allergic to penecillin then it's almost certain your allergic to amoxicillin or any "CILLIN" for that matter. But we would never know unless we did some sort of blood testing or a skin prick test to see if you were. Not knowing the entire history of a person and their background makes it very hard to give advice. 9 out of 10 times the person will fail to tell the physician something and WHAM thats when the crap hits the fan and everyones in trouble. Most Physicians won't even see you as a favor to a friend of theirs because of this. There's just no real way to give you a 100% correct answer to your question.
 
Koevoet said:
Agreed. Believe it or not the fact that we are not licensed physicians actually protects us in a way.

Yes this is true. Malpractice has gotten so dominate in the US and some other countries, a smart doctor would not take the chance without a disclaimer.
 
Look you guys. you've all taken a negative view toward this. A doctor knows what kind of advice to give when to give it and under what circumstances to or not to diagnose a problem. we don't need a doctor to diagnose here. We're just looking for advice/ info regarding sports medicine. Of course a doctor would not try to diagnose without an exam. Physicians know how far to go in giving advice. Example: If a forum member states he has a possible abscess the doctor will give common signs and symptoms of an abscess, the doc will most likely always use the default statement: consult your physician.
Ask Phil... he knows the other board which has a Physician post in a separate forum and its a very useful forum.
 
BOOMSHAKER said:
An MD can also tell you to take some penecillin not knowing you were allergic to it and you croak! If you are allergic to penecillin then it's almost certain your allergic to amoxicillin or any "CILLIN" for that matter. But we would never know unless we did some sort of blood testing or a skin prick test to see if you were. Not knowing the entire history of a person and their background makes it very hard to give advice. 9 out of 10 times the person will fail to tell the physician something and WHAM thats when the crap hits the fan and everyones in trouble. Most Physicians won't even see you as a favor to a friend of theirs because of this. There's just no real way to give you a 100% correct answer to your question.

A doctor would never prescribe anything unless they examen you personally. Poor argument bro.
 
DaRooster said:
A doctor would never prescribe anything unless they examen you personally. Poor argument bro.


I never said prescribe, I said suggest(although I didn't use the word) I just assumed we all knew a physician telling you to get something means "go to your Doc and ask him to prescribe it". But never did i say the board Doc would prescribe it. I think you read that a little wrong my friend.
 
I THINK IT'S A GOOD IDEA.

A VERY GOOD IDEA.:D :D
 
DaRooster said:
Look you guys. you've all taken a negative view toward this. A doctor knows what kind of advice to give when to give it and under what circumstances to or not to diagnose a problem. we don't need a doctor to diagnose here. We're just looking for advice/ info regarding sports medicine. Of course a doctor would not try to diagnose without an exam. Physicians know how far to go in giving advice. Example: If a forum member states he has a possible abscess the doctor will give common signs and symptoms of an abscess, the doc will most likely always use the default statement: consult your physician.
Ask Phil... he knows the other board which has a Physician post in a separate forum and its a very useful forum.
Don't get me wrong, I do think it is a good idea with a ton of potential benefits. I just also believe that if it is done it has to be handled very carefully and within a very specific set of rules in order to protect the doctor, the board, and all us from any liability.
 
Didnt we agree to hold this forum free from any liability when we signed up? If so, then theres nothing we can do.

Also, the Doc doesnt have to list his real name or anything, just as long as Big A lets us know that hes a real doc.

If you sue this person, youre very retarded and will look even more retarded when you say "the doc didnt give me the right advice when I was taking my steroids."

Finally, arent we all role playing anyway? ;)
 
I like the basic idea, would need to be worked on but overall a nice idea.......
 
BOOMSHAKER said:
I never said prescribe, I said suggest(although I didn't use the word) I just assumed we all knew a physician telling you to get something means "go to your Doc and ask him to prescribe it". But never did i say the board Doc would prescribe it. I think you read that a little wrong my friend.
Try Going to your Provider and ask him for some penicillin.... and see what happens. If he/she doesn't find reason for you to be prescribed that medication he wont care who said you should have penicillin. Go to:
www.millenium-muscle.net (even though millenium is supposed to be 2 n's..I think) And see how well that Physician answers questions without fear.
 
If a MD wants to come on here and give adice, hey by all means go for it! I have no problem with it. I'm a nobody who is just putting in his .02.
 
BOOMSHAKER said:
If a MD wants to come on here and give adice, hey by all means go for it! I have no problem with it. I'm a nobody who is just putting in his .02.
I'm not trying to be difficult bro just easing fears that a Doc wouldn't want to be on here. Granted most Docs wouldn't touch the anabolic subject with a Ten foot poll but there are some that will. I'm sure Big A knows a few that may be willing to come on board. Any way I think having a Physician on staff here would be invaluable.
 
It's a lot of grey area and the laws are not fully defined yet which makes the environment even more hostile. Even if you misdiagnose a patient and you're taken to court and the court finds you were NOT negligent, you're probably going to be dropped anyway by your carrier and probably get reviewed by the bar. Laws also vary from state to state.

It's interesting to note that a doctor or lawyer can provide professional advice via a book or even phone, yet the internet has not been clearly defined. By now it should be obvious to everyone that technology moves far faster than the legislative process. Furthermore, there seems to be nothing to prevent a person from publishing a book on "Home Remedies" which could possibly prevent a person from getting the medication they need and result in serious consequences for the patient.

You have to look at it in a manner which is more akin to a parent/child relationship than an adult/adult relationship. The professional community assumes that non-professionals are mindless children that will do or take anything as advised without any thought or responsibility whatsoever and the professional can be held liable for any damage or injury that occurs to the non-professional (patient, client, etc.) as a result of that advice. Someone could have an painful hangnail and if the doctor said "We need to cut that finger off." and the person did it... Who's responsible? Definitely not the person with nine fingers. The only thing the guy with the missing finger is guilty of is blatant stupidity - and there's no law against stupidity yet.

The only thing you can do is not give any advice other than general advice and refer everyone to a professional in any specific circumstance. Having an MD on here would be fine if he wants to write articles and post general statements but it would be extremely wise for him to refer people to a local doctor before giving them medical advice or treatment and never NEVER charge for any service.
 
DaRooster said:
Any way I think having a Physician on staff here would be invaluable.


And with that I will say ABSOLUTELY correct, better to be safe then sorry on any medical subject!

(did we just agree? :D ) j/k
 
OuchThatHurts said:
It's a lot of grey area and the laws are not fully defined yet which makes the environment even more hostile. Even if you misdiagnose a patient and you're taken to court and the court finds you were NOT negligent, you're probably going to be dropped anyway by your carrier and probably get reviewed by the bar. Laws also vary from state to state.

It's interesting to note that a doctor or lawyer can provide professional advice via a book or even phone, yet the internet has not been clearly defined. By now it should be obvious to everyone that technology moves far faster than the legislative process. Furthermore, there seems to be nothing to prevent a person from publishing a book on "Home Remedies" which could possibly prevent a person from getting the medication they need and result in serious consequences for the patient.

You have to look at it in a manner which is more akin to a parent/child relationship than an adult/adult relationship. The professional community assumes that non-professionals are mindless children that will do or take anything as advised without any thought or responsibility whatsoever and the professional can be held liable for any damage or injury that occurs to the non-professional (patient, client, etc.) as a result of that advice. Someone could have an painful hangnail and if the doctor said "We need to cut that finger off." and the person did it... Who's responsible? Definitely not the person with nine fingers. The only thing the guy with the missing finger is guilty of is blatant stupidity - and there's no law against stupidity yet.

The only thing you can do is not give any advice other than general advice and refer everyone to a professional in any specific circumstance. Having an MD on here would be fine if he wants to write articles and post general statements but it would be extremely wise for him to refer people to a local doctor before giving them medical advice or treatment and never NEVER charge for any service.

You guys are looking into this far to much. Give most Physician some credit. They are not stupid. They know what they can and cant do.
 

Forum statistics

Total page views
575,879,408
Threads
138,414
Messages
2,856,096
Members
161,429
Latest member
Clintb
NapsGear
HGH Power Store email banner
yourdailyvitamins
Prowrist straps store banner
yourrawmaterials
3
raws
Savage Labs Store email
Syntherol Site Enhancing Oil Synthol
aqpharma
yms-GIF-210x131-Banne-B
hulabs
ezgif-com-resize-2-1
MA Research Chem store banner
MA Supps Store Banner
volartek
Keytech banner
thc
Godbullraw-bottom-banner
Injection Instructions for beginners
YMS-210x131-V02
Back
Top