Creatine HCL

[BigTex]

Anyone tried this stuff? Opinions? This is an injectable form of creatine.

 

[beeman]

Why would you think that adding an HCl on something makes it injectable. For creatine to work it has to be injected in the cell, not just in to a muscle. Anyone who would try this has more balls than brains I think.

 

[EDED]

beeman, people drink creatine and get results, we all know that works, studies show as well,,,so you are saying it needs to injected with a micro needle into muscle cells to work? then how come people are getting results from it drinking? also HCL means this is a salt version, you can make anything injectable pretty much, the question is will it work or not, is it stable?

bigtex, i think i know who you are talking about, now i know after your ractopamine post hehehe,

you know i was thinking; liquid creatine may not work, not sure if HCL salt version is stable in liquid or not but they stopped making liquid drinkable creatine back in the day cuz someone said once in liquid, creatine got destroyed or something. Could be samething here or this may work.

so im not too sure on this one,,,im not sure on racto either we should have some guinea pig try both and tell us LOL

 

[beeman]

I may have been a little to jumpy because I am used to dumb questions, but I do not see any extra benefit even if an injectable form was available. I think there used to actually be a product called neoton or something like that but it never took off because it wasnt practical. If we are injecting creatine phosphate maybe but how is that going to make it more effective than oral. It would have to circulate in the systemic circulation before being stored, just as the oral would.

Maybe I am missing something though.

 

[Ashop]

Anyone tried this stuff? Opinions? This is an injectable form of creatine.

Not yet. Creatine mono and CEE works well for me already.

 

[EDED]

I may have been a little to jumpy because I am used to dumb questions, but I do not see any extra benefit even if an injectable form was available. I think there used to actually be a product called neoton or something like that but it never took off because it wasnt practical. If we are injecting creatine phosphate maybe but how is that going to make it more effective than oral. It would have to circulate in the systemic circulation before being stored, just as the oral would.

Maybe I am missing something though.

was neoton an injectable? never heard of it, probably didnt work lol.

yes i agree with you, if stuff works by drinking it, why shoot it? and how much better will it be? highly doubtful.

who knows maybe its good

 

[GPenn]

Obviously the only benefit to having something injected is that you don't have to rely on the digestive system for uptake. As for as I know there is no real need to inject creatine, so stay safe and swallow the stuff. The real question should be does creatine HCL work(when swallowed). It is suppose to have higher muscle absorption as well as intestinal uptake. Has anyone had this experience or found some evidence? I've been searching about this stuff for weeks and haven't come to any solid conclusion. Most research is on monohydrate.