Don't disagree with anything you said. I believe all these programs work.. just the way Mike talks about training, it comes off as overcomplicating it. Where DC, jm, Scott, Dorian..even Milos...keep things much simpler and explain their approach in a way that doesn't cause confusion. Essentially I think he appeals to the crowd that are searching to optimize all variables all the time...vs focus on the big rocks and be consistent. The crowd of searching for optimization is not a good place for most to be...and those types will benefit from listening to those that guide them back to the basics... essentially what you mentioned in your post.
Full transparency… I’m friends with Dante, Scott, Mike Israetel, and Charly (not mentioned in this thread, but he is closely tied to Mike, even though they are no longer in business together). I’ll be as honest as I can be.
Have you ever heard Scott’s long winded podcasts? He nuances the nuances and almost never gives a straight answer. He makes you think, but I love it. Most people can’t tolerate it because they get so lost. I have to translate a lot of stuff he says for my friends who can’t bother to sit through it.
Mike? Same, but he does give more direct info. I love the quality of his content, but he’s VERY arrogant, and I just wish he’d be more honest in his personal short comings and take advice from others like we all have.
Dorian? I would never take advice from him. He’s so simple that he comes off as ignorant… and his training advice is hot garbage… sometimes just factually incorrect. He personally accomplished a lot, but if he gave a free training seminar at my local gym, I would not go. I’d smoke a joint with him and pet his dog, but probably never listen to him about back training.
Bodybuilding content is like porn. We don’t all click on the same genre, and some genre’s may turn us off.
I like the overly nuanced content of Scott, Mike, Vigorous Steve, Paul Barnett, Kurt Havens, Todd Lee.. If you don’t explain the “why” well enough, I just won’t listen. Other people may not care about the “why” at all.
Different strokes for different folks.