- Joined
- Oct 20, 2005
- Messages
- 816
The Volume VS. HIT debate never seems to end, and this is good because it promotes healthy discussion and enhances our understanding of the science of training and muscle growth.
The HIT system is a product of the late Arthur Jones and was made popular by the late Mike Mentzer, myself and by Dorian Yates – a Mr. Olympia against whom I competed. There’s no doubt that the HIT system works – but it doesn’t work as advertised. Let me explain.
Whereas volume training involves doing one warm-up set and then 3 or 4 working sets, with the final working set going to failure (point at which you cannot perform another unassisted repetition), HIT advocates claim that HIT requires only one set to totally fatigue your muscle fibers – but this just isn’t true.
The HIT system does include performing some sets that are not taken to failure – about 3 or 4, just as in volume training – but the 3 sets before the final working set are “warm-up” sets, and according to the HIT system, do not constitute “sets.” Of course, this is simply a play on words. Everyone knows that if you’re lifting a weight, even if it’s for the purposes of warming up, it constitutes a set.
Scientific studies have shown that doing multiple sets may actually increase hormone levels more than just doing one set. The important thing is that you are recruiting more and more muscle fibers with each succeeding set, until virtually ALL fibers are recruited in the final set. This is where REAL results come from. For most people, it takes them 2-3 sets to get to the point where they can finally recruit all the fibers in the muscle group they are training. This point is called the “growth threshold” and is discussed on page 112 of the Lean Body Promise (www.leanbodypromise.com )
Hope that helps! Happy Lifting.
-Lee
The HIT system is a product of the late Arthur Jones and was made popular by the late Mike Mentzer, myself and by Dorian Yates – a Mr. Olympia against whom I competed. There’s no doubt that the HIT system works – but it doesn’t work as advertised. Let me explain.
Whereas volume training involves doing one warm-up set and then 3 or 4 working sets, with the final working set going to failure (point at which you cannot perform another unassisted repetition), HIT advocates claim that HIT requires only one set to totally fatigue your muscle fibers – but this just isn’t true.
The HIT system does include performing some sets that are not taken to failure – about 3 or 4, just as in volume training – but the 3 sets before the final working set are “warm-up” sets, and according to the HIT system, do not constitute “sets.” Of course, this is simply a play on words. Everyone knows that if you’re lifting a weight, even if it’s for the purposes of warming up, it constitutes a set.
Scientific studies have shown that doing multiple sets may actually increase hormone levels more than just doing one set. The important thing is that you are recruiting more and more muscle fibers with each succeeding set, until virtually ALL fibers are recruited in the final set. This is where REAL results come from. For most people, it takes them 2-3 sets to get to the point where they can finally recruit all the fibers in the muscle group they are training. This point is called the “growth threshold” and is discussed on page 112 of the Lean Body Promise (www.leanbodypromise.com )
Hope that helps! Happy Lifting.
-Lee