On the whole, who would you say are the more "Healthy" bunch? Meaning, they stick to doses relatively non-dangerous and have diets that are health conscious and have an overall greater awareness of their lifestyle in regards to bodybuilding and their drug intake
top physiques at a gymrat level (lets say the top 5 guys at a gym in a large metro city area like LA, who are already big/lean enough to do damage as a LHW/HW/SHW but don't have any desire to diet and compete).
or
National and State level competitors (non pro) who may compete anywhere from once to several times per year
Think you kind of answered your own question in your first post bro. Honestly i'd think as an overall in general would be the more competitive level bodybuilder simply because they would be the most careful with anything and everything they put in their body as far as gear/vitamins/food, etc. When you're at that level you know what kind of gear and how much you need and even more so exactly how and what to eat and it's usually always very healthy and whole foods.
Now the average gym rat that i've seen/met too many to count that use, just use as much gear as possible for their lack luster of everything mentioned above, diet/vitamins/h2o, health etc. The average gym rat more so would do it to look the best at his gym, not on stage, and of course to look the best on the beach for the ladies and at the club. This person then also usually parties often, drinks, maybe rec drugs, on top of higher amounts of gear and compounds with a much cheaper and poorer diet then the competitor.
Are there exceptions, of course. Right now i would be considered a gym rat since i have never competed but would want to one day but since using gear have always ate healthy, never partied hard, drank, did rec drugs, and use sensible doses over the years. Just saying in general though of course and have yet to meet someone in person at the gym who is like me. They all just use tons of gear, have crap diets, party, and ask me WTF am I on and how much are my doses cus i look 10x better then them. I always explain my diet and in detail to them and they just shrug me off and walk away as if i'm lying and i must be doing at least 1g of test, .5 grams of tren, and 50iu/week of hgh.